Showing posts with label the gender gap. Show all posts
Showing posts with label the gender gap. Show all posts

Tuesday, 9 April 2013

#ReaditMD13 - "The Gender Gap" Are Dads the 'toughest sell' when it comes to reading to their kids and breaking gender moulds?

Come on Dad, break the mould!
In the process of this year of gathering together #ReadItMummiesandDaddies2013 stories, anecdotes, links and brilliant brilliant supporters (that's you lot, by the way) we've heard the same thing again and again. In fact it's still something that niggles away at the back of my mind whenever a new national campaign to get parents reading to their kids is announced. Dads are a very tough sell. You are. We are, and it's probably why the big headline grabbing national Booktrust campaign spearheaded by The Duchess of Cornwall and James Patterson specifically singles out and focuses on dads reading to their kids.

Not all dads, of course. We've been bowled over by the response from a lot of dads who recognise the importance of reading to their children and actually thrive on that connection and interaction, as well as that quality time. So why is the message still not getting through?

Some of it seems to have a lot to do with this week's #readitMD13 theme - the gender gap. From the experiences gained so far this year and in the years we've been writing this blog, we find that mums seem to naturally assume the role of storyteller and bedtime book reader more readily than dads (some dads - again, we cannot over-emphasize that this is by no means a black-and-white / open and shut thing, with a whole raft of factors that contribute to why dads either don't or can't read to their children as regularly as they would like to!)

Dads that do read to their children (girls or boys) will also tend to play it safe, and stick to the sort of books that they would have read as a kid themselves. I am extremely guilty of this at times, I find it really tough to read anything overtly 'girly' to Charlotte but I do try and ensure there's a good spread and balance in the stuff we read.

Speaking to a lot of dads, we've found that again and again this ties in with their own experiences, and some also carry this beyond just the children's books but into other areas of their parenting as well (for example, dads with daughters are quite happy to play with Lego with their little girl but wouldn't play with dolls, princesses or 'domestic' roleplay stuff).

Trying to crack this tough nut and get to the root of what we (dads) are worried about is like twiddling about with an unexploded bomb and a monkey wrench. Perhaps it's the fear that over time, challenging a child's perception of gender boundaries will radically alter their behaviour and preferences for the worst in later life (which sounds completely daft, I can't imagine how or why this could possibly be the case but I've heard it far too many times from dads to ignore it).

Or perhaps it's because parents (not just dads) prefer the notion that a child will be more readily accepted by their peers later on in life (in school etc) if they go with those pre-built ideas of masculinity and femininity programmed in.

I'll leave you with an anecdote from the founder of Bookstart, Wendy Cooling - who I completely failed to recognise but was very lucky to meet earlier this year - talking about the scale of the problem of gender stereotyping linked to books.

Regularly, the organisation encounters fierce resistance and criticism from parents (particularly dads) who strongly argue that some book choices will somehow 'turn their children gay / effeminate' (this story was told completely straight facedly to a room full of gathered booky folk who couldn't quite believe what they were hearing).

If an organisation that offers free (and brilliant) book packs to children, chosen extremely carefully, can meet that sort of resistance then it's going to take all of us and a heck of a lot more effort than we think to challenge, change and eradicate that kind of thinking.

But oh my, it'll be a change for the better, don't you think?
Read More

Monday, 8 April 2013

#ReaditMD13 - The Gender Gap 'Boy Books and Girl Books'

Old-fashioned stereotyping or shrewd marketing?
We're hoping you missed us a teeny weeny bit while we took a blog break (once again I'm in awe of anyone who can manage a blog and their kids at the same time). But we're now back and we're cracking straight on with our #ReadItMummiesandDaddies2013 campaign theme weeks.

This week we thought we'd tackle the thorny subject of 'girl' books and 'boy' books. It's a controversial piece of marketing that creeps into books just as it does into other forms of entertainment or pastimes for children and it's one that's about as welcome as Darth Vader in a kissing booth. 

It's easy to see why such divisions are still promoted and still regularly happen. A subtle tweak, a colour change and you can double your market share with books that look 'tailored' to their audience. 

As we've all too often seen though, the division goes deeper than just colour, reinforcing stereotypes that parents would rather had stayed back in Victorian times. Quaint ideas that only boys like dinosaurs, while girls are quite happy making things or cooking. 

At home, we regularly find that despite our best efforts, well-meaning friends and family unintentionally subvert our attempts to ensure that Charlotte gets a good spread of books that are non-gender specific. Sometimes though it does feel like no one actually asks her what she likes or what she's into and just imagines that all girls (including Charlotte) will love the frilly pink cutesy stories when they'd probably have a shock if they saw the sort of books she regularly pulls from her shelves and demands to have read to her again and again. 

Like all kids, boy or girl, she changes her mind as often as the wind changes direction and that's why it saddens me when I hear stories from other parents - or from the lovely book folk we've met through this blog who regularly encounter the gender gap not only being fed but actually encouraged and reinforced. The bizarre notion that boys will be less 'effective' as alpha males if they dare read the likes of Alice in Wonderland or anything even remotely cute, or for that matter featuring a strong female lead character rather than some rough and tumble boy. 

The flip side is also that there are parents who are quite happy for their little girl to read nothing but the frilly pink stuff. On Twitter, it's quite interesting to note the effect on a company who dares put out a set of blue and pink toys, activities or books - and how quickly those companies attempt to either justify their actions or back down so the question is, why do it in the first place? We're back to marketing again...

We aim to encourage parents to read to their children with our campaign, but sometimes you also have to also hope with all your heart that they're going to read the right stuff, and leave books that negatively reinforce these stereotypes exactly where they are. 

Read More